When tragedy strikes, we instinctively ask “Why?” Scripture doesn’t offer easy answers—but it does reveal a faithful God who enters our suffering, redeems it through love, and rules sovereignly with compassion. God’s sovereignty is not distant control but redemptive presence—the power to bring good out of even the darkest events.
Few questions challenge faith more than this: If God is good and powerful, why do bad things happen?
It’s an ancient question—the psalmists cried it, Job wrestled with it, and Jesus Himself lamented, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”
This question matters not just in theology, but in every hospital room, every graveside, every moment of heartbreak. And yet, through the witness of Scripture and the saints, we learn that God’s sovereignty and human suffering are not contradictions—they are mysteries held together in the cross of Christ.
1. God’s Sovereignty Is Loving, Not Controlling
In Wesleyan theology, God’s sovereignty is the sovereignty of love. God’s rule is not arbitrary power but perfect, self-giving goodness.
John Wesley wrote, “God is the fountain of all holiness and happiness; His very nature is love.”
This means that God does not will evil, but in His freedom allows human and natural processes to unfold—while also working within them to redeem, restore, and renew. God’s sovereignty is not the author of pain, but the architect of redemption.
Romans 8:28 affirms this: “In all things God works for the good of those who love Him, who are called according to His purpose.” Notice: not all things are good—but God works good through all things.
2. The Early Church: Mystery, Freedom, and Hope
The early church fathers refused to treat suffering as meaningless.
- Irenaeus of Lyons (2nd century) taught that suffering can serve as the context for spiritual growth—the “soul-making” by which believers mature in Christlike love.
- Athanasius reminded the church that in the incarnation, God Himself entered human suffering: “He took what is ours, that He might give us what is His.”
- Gregory the Great saw trials as both mystery and mercy—opportunities where divine grace reshapes the human heart toward holiness.
For these early voices, sovereignty was not about deterministic control, but about a God whose power is co-suffering love—one who brings resurrection out of crucifixion.
3. The Book of Job and the Cross of Christ
Job’s story helps us face suffering without false comfort. Job never receives a detailed explanation for his pain. Instead, God reveals His vastness and care, reminding Job that His ways are beyond human comprehension (Job 38–42).
Job’s peace returns not through answers, but through encounter—he sees God’s sovereignty and mercy firsthand.
The ultimate revelation of this comes in Jesus Christ. On the cross, God does not explain suffering—He enters it.
In Christ crucified, we see the paradox: the worst evil ever committed—the killing of the innocent Son of God—becomes the means by which all evil is overcome. The cross reveals that divine sovereignty is cruciform—power expressed through sacrificial love.
4. Wesleyan Grounding: Grace in the Midst of Suffering
Wesley often preached that suffering is not proof of God’s absence but the arena of sanctifying grace.
He wrote, “God will either make a way to escape or bear us up under it.”
Grace doesn’t always remove pain, but it gives strength to endure and transform it. God’s sovereignty is expressed not by preventing every sorrow, but by giving grace sufficient for each moment (2 Corinthians 12:9).
In our trials, grace draws us deeper into Christ’s likeness—turning despair into dependence, and fear into faith.
5. Practical Ways to Live with Trust in God’s Sovereignty
- Pray Honestly: God can handle your questions. The Psalms of lament (e.g., Psalms 13, 22, 42) are prayers of faith that trust even through confusion.
- Cling to Christ: Fix your eyes on Jesus, the One who suffered with and for us. Remember, His resurrection promises that suffering does not have the last word.
- Join in Suffering Love: Comfort others who suffer. As we share in others’ pain, we become part of God’s redemptive work.
- Stay Rooted in the Means of Grace: Word, prayer, Eucharist, community, and acts of mercy are how the Spirit sustains faith through mystery.
- Choose Hope Daily: When evil seems to win, declare: “Christ has died. Christ is risen. Christ will come again.” That confession is the heartbeat of Christian hope.
Reflection Questions
- What experiences of suffering have challenged your understanding of God’s goodness?
- How does the cross of Christ reshape how you view God’s sovereignty?
- Which Scripture brings you peace when you cannot understand God’s plan?
- How might you show God’s love to someone walking through pain this week?
Prayer
Sovereign and merciful God,
When life breaks and we cannot see Your purpose, hold us fast in Your love.
Teach us to trust not in explanations, but in Your presence.
Redeem what evil intends for harm and use it for good.
Help us rest in Your faithfulness until the day when all tears are wiped away.
Through Jesus Christ, crucified and risen, Amen.
Next Steps
- Meditate on Romans 8 or Job 38–42 this week, journaling what they teach you about God’s sovereignty.
- Write a testimony of how God has worked good from a painful experience.
- Reach out to someone who is suffering—be present, pray with them, and listen without trying to fix.
- Pray daily: “God, I don’t always understand, but I trust that You are good.”
R Y A N S T R A T T O N 